Class 4 impact-resistant shingles are worth it in Utah when they are the rubberized kind, called SBS. Rubber in the asphalt lets those shingles flex under hail, and they age more slowly. Some insurers give a discount for a Class 4 roof, so ask yours. I recommend them for how long they last, not the discount.
Choose a rubberized SBS Class 4 shingle, and ask your insurer about a discount before the roof goes on.
Rubber in the asphalt lets the shingle flex when hail hits, so it cracks less and lasts longer.
Call your insurance agent and ask whether a Class 4 roof lowers your premium.
On a Utah roof I recommend Class 4 rubberized shingles for how long they last. Any break on your insurance is a bonus.
Mattie Tueller, Master Roofing
A shingle is Class 4 when it passes the top level of a lab impact test called UL 2218. In that test, steel balls are dropped on the shingle. A Class 4 shingle takes a 2-inch ball without cracking through.
| Impact class | Steel ball it must survive |
|---|---|
| Class 1 | 1.25 inches |
| Class 2 | 1.5 inches |
| Class 3 | 1.75 inches |
| Class 4 | 2 inches |
Some shingles also pass a second test, FM 4473, which fires balls of ice instead of steel. Owens Corning lists both ratings on its Duration FLEX shingles. The rating tells you the steel ball didn't crack the shingle all the way through. That matters, because a crack through the shingle is where water gets in.
Rubberized Class 4 shingles, called SBS, are the ones that last longer on a Utah roof. Both kinds pass the hail test, but they get there in different ways:
Ask the roofer which kind is on your bid, because the words Class 4 alone don't tell you. The asphalt in all shingles has changed, which is why shingles don't last as long as they used to.
Some insurance companies give a discount for a Class 4 roof, but it depends on your carrier and your policy. Owens Corning says its Class 4 rating may qualify for a homeowner insurance discount. Only your insurer can tell you if yours does. Here's how to find out:
Even with no discount, I'd still put Class 4 SBS shingles on a Utah roof, for how long they last. Your policy also decides what a Utah roof insurance claim actually pays.
A tougher roof matters because some homeowners policies no longer pay for a whole new roof after hail. A policy that pays actual cash value pays what a new roof costs, minus depreciation. The Utah Insurance Department defines depreciation by the roof's age and condition. On an older roof, you pay the gap.
After a storm, start by checking whether hail actually damaged your roof. Then decide whether to file a claim or pay for it yourself.
As a Utah roofing contractor, my answer on Class 4 shingles has changed in the last two years. Two years ago I'd have said yes, but only because of what's in them. The SBS rubber in the asphalt helps a shingle weather more slowly. That's why the roof lasts longer.
I still say yes, and now there's a second reason. Many homeowners policies I see in Utah now pay an older roof's depreciated value after hail. So when a storm comes through, more of the bill lands on you. That's why at Master Roofing, a Utah roofing company, we recommend SBS Class 4 shingles, not just any shingle with a Class 4 label.
The thick-mat kind does pass the test fairly. It keeps hail from breaking through, and that's what keeps water out. But it ages like a regular shingle. A shingle that lasts longer and takes hail well is a roof you pay for less often. You end up replacing it less, whatever your policy pays.
This article is general information about Utah roofs, not an assessment of yours. Every roof is different, and no article can tell you what is actually happening on your specific house. Have a licensed roofing contractor look at it in person before you act on anything here.
Hail can still damage a Class 4 roof, especially the thick-mat kind. The test only shows that a 2-inch steel ball didn't crack through. Hail can still scar the top of a thick-mat shingle. In my experience, SBS rubberized shingles flex when they're hit, so they show much less damage after a storm.
A Class 4 roof won't stop depreciation on an actual cash value policy, because depreciation follows the roof's age and condition. What a Class 4 roof changes is how often hail damages it in the first place. A roof that comes through a storm with no damage never needs a claim, so depreciation never comes up.
To know if a shingle is SBS, look at the maker's product sheet for the words SBS, polymer-modified or rubberized. Malarkey's Vista sheet says SBS rubberized, and Owens Corning calls Duration FLEX SBS polymer-modified. If your bid only says Class 4, ask the roofer for the exact shingle name, then look it up.
Your insurance may not pay to match the rest of your roof after hail. In my experience, some policies cap what they'll pay toward the undamaged side, so you can end up with mismatched slopes. Utah's insurance rule says a replacement cost policy must give a reasonably uniform look. Ask your agent how yours works before a storm.
We're here to see what's going on with your roof. A real assessment starts with your history and your attic, not a number from the driveway. You'll get a straight answer about what's up there, what it needs, and what it costs. Sometimes the honest answer is: your roof looks great.