Shingle color matters a little in Utah's sun, but less than most people think. In a Florida study of vented attics, dark shingles ran the attic only about 3 degrees warmer on average. Lighter shingles last slightly longer. I'd get the attic ventilation right first, then pick the color you like.
Get your attic ventilation right first, then choose the shingle color you like best.
A well-vented attic carries off most of the extra heat a darker roof soaks up from the sun.
Ask your roofer whether your attic meets code for intake and exhaust vents.
In Utah's long winters a darker roof can even help a little. Shingle color is a small choice next to the attic under it.
Mattie Tueller, Master Roofing
A dark shingle roof makes a vented attic only a little hotter on average, but a lot hotter at the hottest part of the day. The Florida Solar Energy Center tested side-by-side homes with vented attics in July 2000. Here's what it measured:
| Attic air temperature | Dark gray shingles | White shingles |
|---|---|---|
| Average | 90.8 degrees | 88.0 degrees |
| Peak | 135.6 degrees | 123.5 degrees |
So the white roof's attic averaged about 3 degrees cooler and peaked about 12 degrees cooler. At its peak, the dark roof's attic ran 40 degrees above the outside air. That's a sign those attics needed more ventilation, not just a lighter roof. The test was a Florida summer, so Utah numbers will differ.
Attic ventilation matters more than shingle color because it controls how much heat stays trapped under the roof, whatever color is on top. A well-vented attic runs within about 20 degrees of the outside air. A poorly vented one can get far hotter. The hottest attic we've measured hit 180 degrees.
Most roofs we look at, even brand-new ones, aren't vented correctly. If your top floor stays hot after sundown, here's how a hot attic keeps your upstairs warm at night.
Lighter-colored shingles last slightly longer in Utah, because the asphalt runs cooler and dries out more slowly. A darker shingle soaks up more of the sun's heat every day it's up there.
Here's more on how Utah's sun ages a roof.
A darker roof can be slightly better in Utah, because our climate needs more heating than cooling. National Weather Service climate normals show Salt Lake City needs about 5,154 heating degree days a year and about 1,420 cooling degree days. That's more than three times as much heating as cooling. A darker roof soaks up a little winter sun, which helps a little.
To choose your shingle color:
For the big picture, here's what attic ventilation has to do with your roof.
As a roofing contractor in Utah, I get asked whether a dark roof will cook the house. Darker roofs are hotter, so it's a fair question. But if the roof is vented correctly, the difference in your living space is very small. In my experience, it's two or three degrees.
The trouble is that most roofs we see aren't vented correctly. That includes brand-new roofs, and their attics run extremely hot. So the color gets blamed for heat that really comes from the attic. That's why at Master Roofing, a Utah roofing company, we check intake and exhaust ventilation on every roof. Then we build it to meet code.
Color still matters a little. Lighter shingles stay cooler, so the asphalt dries out slower and lasts a bit longer. On the other hand, Utah has long winters, and a darker roof can help warm the house a little. Get the ventilation right, and then you're free to pick the color you love. Your home stays comfortable either way.
This article is general information about Utah roofs, not an assessment of yours. Every roof is different, and no article can tell you what is actually happening on your specific house. Have a licensed roofing contractor look at it in person before you act on anything here.
Dark shingles can raise a summer cooling bill somewhat. In a Florida test, white shingles cut cooling energy by about 3 to 5 percent compared with dark gray shingles. Utah needs far more heating than cooling over a year, though, and good attic ventilation does more for comfort than color does.
A lighter roof makes an upstairs only a little cooler if the attic is vented well. When the top floor stays hot after sundown, the cause is usually a hot attic giving off heat all night. Check the ventilation before you pay for a color change.
Color matters on a metal roof in Utah mostly for how it looks years later, because some colors fade badly in our sun. Red fades fastest here. Ask your roofer which metal colors have held up on Utah homes, and look at a roof that's been up a few years.
Your attic is vented well enough if it stays within about 20 degrees of the outside air on a hot afternoon. A cheap thermometer in the attic will tell you. If it runs much hotter, ask a roofer to check the intake and exhaust vents against code.
We're here to see what's going on with your roof. A real assessment starts with your history and your attic, not a number from the driveway. You'll get a straight answer about what's up there, what it needs, and what it costs. Sometimes the honest answer is: your roof looks great.