Lindon, UT · Serving Salt Lake, Utah, Davis, Summit and Wasatch counties (385) 438-3591

Is synthetic shake or slate worth it over the real thing?

Direct Answer

Synthetic shake and slate are worth it for most Utah homes. Real wood shake isn't allowed where Utah's wildfire code applies, and in my experience it's hard to insure. Real slate costs a fortune and few roofers will repair it. Good synthetics need no upkeep, and two leading brands carry 50-year and lifetime limited warranties.

Mattie Tueller

Mattie Tueller

Owner & General Manager, Master Roofing · Utah License #10694610-5501

Lindon, UT · serving Salt Lake, Utah, Davis, Summit and Wasatch counties

Best Move

Choose a proven synthetic shake or slate, and ask your roofer which brands have had problems.

Why It Works

Synthetics give you the look with no upkeep, a strong fire rating and a roof you can get repaired.

Next Step

Ask your roofer which synthetic brands they've installed and which ones failed.

What you need to know about synthetic shake and slate roofing

In Utah, a good synthetic shake looks like the real thing, needs no upkeep and keeps your home insurable.

Mattie Tueller, Master Roofing

What are the downsides of a real wood shake roof in Utah?

The downsides of a real wood shake roof in Utah are fire rules, insurance and upkeep. Any one of them can be a deal breaker:

  • Fire rules. Where Utah's wildfire code applies, wood shake and wood shingle roofs aren't allowed, and a wood roof can't be replaced with the same thing. Here's how to tell whether Utah's wildfire code applies to your home.
  • Insurance. In my experience, a lot of insurance companies won't write a homeowners policy on a house with a shake roof. Call your agent before you choose wood.
  • Upkeep. Wood needs regular care to last. The Cedar Shake and Shingle Bureau publishes a whole care guide. It warns against treatments that make outrageous claims, and against fly-by-night spray crews. In my experience, hardly anyone keeps up with the care, so shake roofs wear out early.

Is a real slate roof worth the cost in Utah?

A real slate roof is worth the cost for very few Utah homes, even though the slate itself can outlast you. I know of only a handful of real slate roofs in our market. If you think a roof is slate, it's probably a synthetic.

What real slate does well
The stone doesn't wear out. A slate roof can last your lifetime and several more.
Where real slate costs you
The price is very high. Some slates crack when people walk on the roof.
The repair problem
Real slate is so uncommon here that few roofers know how to install or repair it. A small leak can leave you with no one willing to touch it.

That repair problem is why most Utah homeowners who want the slate look choose a synthetic.

How do synthetic shake and slate roofs compare with the real thing?

Synthetic shake and slate roofs compare well with the real thing: they cost less, need no upkeep and carry long warranties. The best ones look so real that you can't tell the difference from the street. Here's how two leading brands describe their synthetic shake on their own pages:

BrandWarrantyImpact ratingFire rating
DaVinci RoofscapesLifetime limited material warrantyClass 4Class A
CEDUR50-year limited warrantyClass 4Class A

Class 4 is the top impact rating, the same test used for impact-resistant shingles. Class A is the top fire rating. Check the exact product, because ratings can differ across a brand's lines.

How do I choose a synthetic shake or slate brand?

To choose a synthetic shake or slate brand, start with your roofer's experience, because some newer products have had problems. Brands on the market include Brava, DaVinci, CEDUR, F-Wave and Euroshield. Stone-coated steel also comes in a shake look. Then work through these steps:

  1. Ask your roofer which brands they've installed and which ones have had issues.
  2. Get the material warranty in writing, and read how long it lasts.
  3. Check the exact product's fire and impact ratings.
  4. Ask to see a roof the company finished a few years ago.

If you like the shake look but want metal's lifespan, here's how asphalt, metal and stone-coated steel compare in Utah.

Mattie's Take

As a roofing contractor in Utah, I hear from a lot of people who love the look of shake and slate. The synthetic versions look really nice. The real materials are just hard to live with here.

With wood shake, it's insurance first. In my experience, a lot of homeowners policies won't cover a shake roof, and fire codes are pushing shake out. Wood also needs care that almost nobody does, so it wears out early. Real slate is the opposite problem. The stone lasts, but it's so expensive and so rare here that finding someone to fix a leak is hard.

The synthetics answer all of that. They look good, last a long time and need no upkeep. They're newer products, though, and some have had issues. So my advice from Master Roofing, a Utah roofing company, is to research the product. Then hire a roofer who knows which brands have problems. Ask which brands have held up, then enjoy a roof you never have to treat.

Before you act on this

This article is general information about Utah roofs, not an assessment of yours. Every roof is different, and no article can tell you what is actually happening on your specific house. Have a licensed roofing contractor look at it in person before you act on anything here.

More questions about synthetic shake and slate roofing

Can people tell a synthetic shake roof from real wood?

People usually can't tell a good synthetic shake roof from real wood, especially from the street. CEDUR says its shakes are made from molds of real cedar. Ask your roofer to show you a finished synthetic roof in person before you decide, because photos can flatter any product.

Do synthetic shake roofs meet Utah's wildfire code?

Synthetic shake roofs can meet Utah's wildfire code when they carry a Class A fire rating, the top rating. DaVinci and CEDUR both list Class A on their own pages. Check the exact product's rating, and check how the wildfire code applies to your home, before you choose. Real wood shake isn't allowed where that code applies.

Can I walk on a real slate roof?

Walking on a real slate roof can crack the slate, so leave it to a roofer who knows slate. That's part of why repairs are hard here. Few roofers in Utah work on real slate, and a cracked piece needs someone who can replace it without breaking the ones around it.

Is stone-coated steel an option if I want a shake look?

Stone-coated steel is an option if you want a shake look, because it comes formed to look like shake as well as shingle and tile. It's a steel roof with a granule coating, and it lasts about 50 years in Utah. That makes it worth comparing with a synthetic shake.

Related pages

Mattie Tueller

Mattie Tueller

Mattie Tueller is the owner and general manager of Master Roofing in Lindon, Utah. He came up through the trades (flooring, tile, and full renovations under a general contractor who expected everything built right), ran statewide operations as a political director, then spent a year inside a sales-first roofing shop and built Master Roofing as its opposite: in-house crews trained by the owner, a dedicated quality check on every job, ventilation built to code on every bid, and warranties that mean what they say. He serves as an expert witness in roofing litigation.

About Master Roofing. Master Roofing is a licensed Utah roofing contractor (license #10694610-5501) based in Lindon and serving homeowners across Salt Lake, Utah, Davis, Summit and Wasatch counties, including Salt Lake City and the Wasatch Front and Back. Owner Mattie Tueller and the company's in-house crews handle roof inspections, hail and wind damage assessments, insurance claims, roof repair and replacement, asphalt shingle and metal roofing, flat and low-slope roofs, skylights, snow retention, gutters and gutter guards, attic ventilation, and Roof Maxx shingle restoration. GAF Master Elite, Owens Corning Preferred, BBB A+.

resources.masterroofingutah.com

We're community focused and here to help.

We're here to see what's going on with your roof. A real assessment starts with your history and your attic, not a number from the driveway. You'll get a straight answer about what's up there, what it needs, and what it costs. Sometimes the honest answer is: your roof looks great.

Book a Free Assessment