A concrete tile roof doesn't make sense on the Wasatch Front, in my experience. Concrete is porous, and our freezing and thawing wears it down, much like a driveway. Clay tile lasts far longer but costs about as much as slate. Tile makes more sense in St. George's heat than it does up here.
Skip concrete tile on the Wasatch Front, and if you still want tile, make Grade 1 the minimum.
In my experience, water works into concrete tile, freezes and expands, and our winters repeat that again and again.
Ask your roofer which roofs give you a tile look that's built for Utah winters.
Up on the Wasatch Front, concrete tile wears like a driveway in our freeze and thaw. In St. George's heat it makes more sense.
Mattie Tueller, Master Roofing
The difference between clay and concrete roof tile comes down to cost and how long each lasts. Clay tile is similar to slate: it lasts a very, very long time, and it's very expensive. That's why most tile roofs are concrete tile.
| What you get | Clay tile | Concrete tile |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | Very high, close to slate | Lower than clay |
| How long it lasts | A very long time | Shorter on the Wasatch Front, in my experience |
| How common it is | Rare | Most tile roofs |
If you want the slate look instead, here's how synthetic shake and slate compare with the real thing.
In my experience, freezing and thawing wears down a concrete tile roof on the Wasatch Front. Water works into the concrete, then freezes and expands, again and again through a Utah winter. Think of your driveway. Here's how I see it happen:
The tile industry sees it differently. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance says Grade 1 tile, rated under ASTM C1492 for concrete, is made to handle harsh winters and freeze-thaw. In my experience on the Wasatch Front and Back, concrete tile still doesn't last as long as people want it to.
If you still want a tile roof in Utah, ask for the toughest tile made and a roofer who's installed it here. Tile is a big, heavy purchase, so go through these steps first:
Whatever you choose, match it to how long you'll live under it. Here's what roofing material lasts longest in Utah's weather.
Stone-coated steel gives you a tile look without the freeze-thaw risk, because it's steel under a stone coating, not concrete. It can be formed to look like Spanish tile, shake or shingle, and it lasts about 50 years in Utah. Other options:
Here's how asphalt, metal and stone-coated steel compare in Utah.
As a roofing contractor in Utah, I get asked about tile roofs by people who love how they look. Clay tile lasts a very long time. It's just very expensive, so most tile you see is concrete.
Concrete is porous. That's why our freeze and thaw is so hard on it. Water works into the pores when it's warm. Then it freezes and expands, and over time that breaks the concrete down, just like your driveway. Concrete also holds the day's heat. Up here, where it cools off at night, that heat keeps coming off the tile and into your house after dark.
Tile makers do rate their best tile for freeze-thaw, and in St. George's extreme heat concrete tile makes more sense. But on the Wasatch Front and Back, concrete tile doesn't last as long as people want it to.
So when someone up here asks us at Master Roofing, a Utah roofing company, about tile, I tell them concrete tile doesn't make sense here. Choose a roof built for our winters, and you won't be paying for cracked tile down the road. You'll get the look you want for longer.
This article is general information about Utah roofs, not an assessment of yours. Every roof is different, and no article can tell you what is actually happening on your specific house. Have a licensed roofing contractor look at it in person before you act on anything here.
Clay tile is better than concrete tile in Utah's winters if your budget allows, because it lasts a very, very long time. The catch is cost: clay tile is priced close to slate. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance rates Grade 1 clay tile under ASTM C1167 for freeze-thaw, so ask for that grade.
A concrete tile roof is heavy. Eagle Roofing lists its standard concrete tiles at about 900 to 970 pounds per 100 square feet. Its lightweight versions run about 550 to 720. Before you choose tile, ask your roofer whether your roof framing was built to carry that weight.
A tile roof meets Utah's wildfire roof rules on its own, because tile doesn't burn. The Tile Roofing Industry Alliance calls tile naturally fireproof. Check how the wildfire code applies to your home before you choose a roof, because the rules depend on where you live.
A tile roof makes more sense in St. George than on the Wasatch Front, because of St. George's extreme heat. Even there, ask for Grade 1 tile, and choose a roofer who's installed tile in southern Utah before.
We're here to see what's going on with your roof. A real assessment starts with your history and your attic, not a number from the driveway. You'll get a straight answer about what's up there, what it needs, and what it costs. Sometimes the honest answer is: your roof looks great.